top of page

A £900 Million Badge of Honour. Another Blow to Healthcare Recruitment.

Nov 5
5 min read

Budget 2026 celebrates a 43% reduction in NHS agency expenditure while introducing further VAT changes for locum doctors. But are we measuring success in the right way?


There was a particular statement buried within the Government's Budget 2026 Red Book that caught my attention, and not necessarily for the reasons the Treasury might have hoped.


In a section celebrating public sector efficiency, the Government proudly highlighted that NHS agency expenditure had fallen by £900 million, representing a 43% reduction in 2025/26 compared with the previous year.


It was presented as evidence that the Government's approach to reducing costs and reliance on temporary staffing was delivering results, almost as though reducing agency expenditure by nearly half should automatically be considered a badge of honour.


Now, I am certainly not suggesting that the NHS should spend more money than necessary on temporary staffing. Public money needs to be spent responsibly, and there are undoubtedly opportunities to improve workforce planning, procurement and the use of permanent staff.


However, I have a fundamental problem with the assumption that reducing agency expenditure is, in itself, a measure of success.


Because the real question should not simply be how much money the NHS has stopped spending on temporary workers. It should be whether patients are receiving better care, whether permanent staff are under less pressure and whether the healthcare workforce is becoming more sustainable.


Those are not necessarily the same things.


When reducing expenditure becomes the objective


Having spent much of my career working across recruitment, staffing and the contingent workforce, I have seen first-hand how easily temporary labour can become the focus of cost reduction programmes.


Agency workers are visible, their costs are relatively easy to identify, and reducing expenditure provides a convenient figure to report to boards, stakeholders and, in this case, the Treasury.


But temporary staffing exists for a reason.


The NHS operates in an environment where demand is unpredictable, specialist skills are not always readily available, and maintaining adequate staffing levels can be the difference between a service operating effectively and one struggling to cope.

Of course, reducing unnecessary dependency on agencies is sensible, particularly where better workforce planning and investment in permanent recruitment can deliver sustainable improvements.


However, reducing agency expenditure without understanding what has replaced that capacity, or whether the demand for it has genuinely disappeared, risks confusing financial savings with operational improvement.


A 43% reduction in expenditure might represent genuine progress, but without the wider workforce and patient outcomes, it tells us remarkably little about whether the NHS is actually in a stronger position.


And then there is the VAT announcement

What makes the Budget's celebration of reduced agency spending particularly interesting is that, elsewhere within the same Budget, the Government announced another change affecting healthcare staffing businesses.


From 1 May 2027, the VAT exemption applying to the supply of a deputy for a registered medical practitioner will be removed, meaning that affected staffing supplies will become subject to the standard rate of VAT.


Importantly, genuine medical care and qualifying deputising services will continue to benefit from VAT exemption, so this is not a blanket change affecting every locum doctor arrangement.


Nevertheless, for recruitment businesses supplying medical professionals under the affected arrangements, the implications could be significant.


Contractual relationships, pricing structures, invoicing systems, cash flow and VAT recovery arrangements will all need to be considered, particularly where existing contracts extend beyond the implementation date.


And while the Government considers this a relatively straightforward correction to the intended VAT treatment, its own impact assessment tells a rather interesting story.


£7 million in additional implementation costs

According to HMRC, the VAT changes are expected to create a significant administrative impact on employment businesses and other organisations supplying medical deputies, with estimated one-off implementation costs of approximately £7 million across affected businesses.


These costs include understanding the new requirements, updating accounting and invoicing systems, and potential VAT registration obligations for smaller organisations.


The Government also expects the measure to raise an additional £85 million in 2027/28, rising to £105 million by 2031/32.


What I find particularly interesting is the contrast between these two announcements.


On one hand, the Government is celebrating the reduction of expenditure on agency staffing as an important efficiency achievement. On the other, it is introducing a taxation change that will generate additional revenue for the Exchequer while creating further implementation costs for businesses operating within that same sector.


The measures are not directly connected, and it would be misleading to suggest that the VAT change will automatically increase NHS costs by 20%, particularly given the VAT recovery arrangements available to certain healthcare organisations.


But that does not mean the broader commercial impact should be dismissed.


Healthcare recruitment businesses are being asked to operate within an increasingly constrained market while absorbing an ever-growing collection of regulatory, administrative and commercial responsibilities.

At some point, that cumulative pressure deserves considerably more attention than it currently receives.


The danger of treating recruitment as the problem

There is a broader issue here that I think is too often overlooked in discussions about healthcare staffing.


Recruitment agencies are frequently portrayed as an expensive alternative to permanent employment, rather than as businesses providing an essential service within a complicated workforce ecosystem.


Are there examples of excessive charging, poor practices and arrangements that do not represent value for money? Of course there are, and those should absolutely be challenged.


But the existence of poor practice does not make the entire temporary staffing model inherently problematic.


Good recruitment businesses provide flexibility, specialist knowledge, workforce availability and the ability to respond quickly when healthcare organisations face unexpected pressures.


They also operate within commercial realities that are becoming increasingly difficult to navigate, with tighter procurement frameworks, margin pressure, regulatory change and declining demand in certain parts of the market.


Add the forthcoming reforms affecting umbrella companies and labour supply chains, and the compliance burden becomes more complicated still.


My concern is that we risk creating an environment where the businesses providing essential workforce flexibility are continually squeezed, without properly considering what happens if that flexibility is no longer commercially viable.


Are we measuring the right things?

Ultimately, this comes back to a question I regularly ask when working with businesses on strategy and leadership: are we measuring what actually matters, or simply what is easiest to measure?


Reducing expenditure is relatively straightforward to quantify, but understanding whether that reduction has improved the underlying organisation requires considerably more thought.

If the NHS has reduced agency spending because it has successfully recruited and retained more permanent staff, improved workforce planning and reduced unnecessary reliance on temporary labour, that is something worth celebrating.


However, if spending has fallen because shifts are going unfilled, services are operating with reduced capacity or existing employees are being asked to shoulder additional pressure, the same headline figure tells a very different story.


The Budget statistic alone cannot tell us which of those outcomes is being achieved.

And that is precisely why celebrating the reduction without giving equal prominence to the wider workforce outcomes feels somewhat premature.


Taking the longer view

I am not arguing that healthcare recruitment should be protected from commercial pressure, taxation changes or appropriate regulation. The sector needs to demonstrate value, maintain high standards and continue adapting to the changing requirements of the NHS.


But Government policy also needs to recognise that workforce sustainability cannot be measured solely through expenditure reduction.


The combination of falling agency spending, additional taxation requirements and increasing regulatory complexity should encourage a much broader conversation about the future of healthcare staffing, rather than another round of congratulations for reducing costs.


Because a reduction in agency expenditure is only a genuine success if it contributes to a stronger, more resilient and more effective healthcare system.


And until we can demonstrate that connection, perhaps we should be a little more cautious about wearing that £900 million saving as a badge of honour.


Sources

HM Treasury, Budget 2026, 28 October 2026.

HM Revenue & Customs, VAT: Removal of the exemption for a deputy for a medical practitioner, 28 October 2026.

Comments


bottom of page